When summer storms start pounding Columbus with hail the size of golf balls, homeowners are left scrambling to protect one of their most valuable investments—their roofs. It begs the question: Are impact-resistant shingles truly worth it when it comes to hail protection? As a trusted residential roofing contractor in Columbus, Van Martin Roofing has seen the devastating effects of Ohio’s unpredictable weather firsthand. This blog dives deep into what homeowners need to know about impact-resistant roofing and whether it’s the right choice to protect your home and peace of mind.

What Are Impact-Resistant Shingles?

Impact-resistant shingles, sometimes labeled as “Class 4” shingles, are specially engineered to withstand more intense weather damage than standard asphalt shingles. But what sets them apart, and do they live up to the hype in hail-prone areas like Central Ohio?

Class Ratings and How They’re Tested

Impact-resistant shingles are tested using a standardized method developed by Underwriters Laboratories (UL), known as UL 2218. This involves dropping steel balls of various sizes onto the shingles to mimic the impact of hailstones.

• Class 1: Withstands impact from a 1.25-inch steel ball

• Class 2: Withstands impact from a 1.5-inch steel ball

• Class 3: Withstands impact from a 1.75-inch steel ball

• Class 4: Withstands impact from a 2-inch steel ball

Ohio’s Hail Threat: How Often Does It Really Happen?

Homeowners in Columbus may underestimate how frequently hail strikes—until it lands in their own backyard. According to NOAA’s Storm Events Database, Ohio averages more than 250 hail events per year. And in 2023 alone, Franklin County experienced 17 confirmed hail storms, with some hailstones exceeding 2 inches in diameter. That’s enough to crack windshields—and certainly enough to destroy unprotected roofs.

What Hail Does to Standard Roof Shingles

Typical asphalt shingles can crack, split, or lose granules when struck by hail. While some damage is obvious, much of it can go unnoticed until a leak forms. This is especially concerning when insurance claims have time limits and roof warranties may become void.

• Cracked or torn shingles may expose your roof decking

• Lost granules reduce a roof’s water resistance

• Small leaks often go unnoticed until extensive interior damage occurs

Benefits of Impact-Resistant Shingles

Are impact-resistant shingles a marketing gimmick or a valuable upgrade? As a SELECT CertainTeed ShingleMaster contractor, Van Martin Roofing can say with confidence—they make a measurable difference, especially in hail-heavy climates like Columbus, Ohio.

Real-World Benefits That Matter

While Class 4 shingles can cost 10%–20% more upfront, the long-term savings and security they offer often justify the expense.

• Reduced Repair Costs: Impact-resistant shingles mean fewer service calls after storms

• Lower Insurance Premiums: Some providers offer discounts for Class 4 shingles

• Extended Roof Life: Greater durability means longer protection before needing a roof replacement in Columbus Ohio

• Warranty Compatibility: Shingle manufacturers like CertainTeed offer enhanced warranties when certified contractors perform installations

Installation Considerations for Columbus Homeowners

Before switching to impact-resistant roofing, homeowners should consult a reputable residential roofing contractor in Columbus like Van Martin Roofing. Quality of installation plays a critical role in shingle performance and warranty coverage.

Working With Certified Installers

Van Martin Roofing is a SELECT ShingleMaster certified by CertainTeed—a designation given only to contractors who demonstrate excellence in roofing knowledge, installation practices, and customer satisfaction. Choosing certified professionals is the first step in maximizing the performance and warranty of your impact-resistant roofing.

• Free inspection to determine roof readiness

• Clear recommendation based on weather exposure and roof slope

• Assistance with insurance and financing options

Cost Breakdown: Impact-Resistant vs. Standard Shingles

Yes, impact-resistant shingles carry a higher price tag—but they also provide long-term value. Here’s a comparison for an average 2,000 sq ft home in Columbus, Ohio:

• Standard Shingles: $6,000–$9,000 (depending on brand and labor)

• Impact-Resistant Shingles: $7,000–$11,000

• Insurance Discount: Up to 25% on your premium with some providers

• Peace of Mind: Priceless, especially after major hail events

Van Martin Roofing offers flexible roofing financing in Columbus so that families can prioritize safety and durability without sacrificing budget stability.

What About Hail Claims? Know Before You Need It

If your roof is damaged by hail, your insurance may cover repairs—but only if you’re proactive. It’s critical to have before-and-after documentation, prompt inspections, and a trusted roofing partner who knows how to navigate insurance claims. Van Martin Roofing offers free inspections and works directly with your insurer to simplify the process.

What Van Martin Does Differently

From providing detailed inspection reports to supporting clients through paperwork, Van Martin Roofing aims to be more than just a contractor—we’re a neighbor you can trust when disaster strikes.

• Detailed photographic evidence for adjusters

• Fast response for emergency roof repair in Columbus

• Certified and insured experts on site within hours

Is It Time to Upgrade Your Roof?

If your current roof is 10+ years old and has endured a few seasons of Ohio’s harsh hailstorms, now is the time to consider upgrading to impact-resistant shingles. Van Martin Roofing’s free roof inspection is the perfect way to evaluate your home’s defenses and learn about affordable roofing options that align with your budget and future needs.

Conclusion

Impact-resistant shingles aren’t just a buzzword—they’re a practical solution to a very real problem facing homeowners in Central Ohio. As hail storms continue to rise in frequency and intensity, the question isn’t just “Are impact-resistant shingles worth it?” but “Can you afford not to have them?” With expert guidance from Van Martin Roofing—Columbus’s trusted residential roofing contractor—you can upgrade your home with confidence and long-lasting protection. Schedule your free inspection today and take the first step toward storm-proof peace of mind.