Should You Replace Your Gutters When You Replace Your Roof?

Should You Replace Your Gutters When You Replace Your Roof?

If you’re investing in a new roof, congratulations—you’re making a smart, long-term decision for your home. But before the shingles go up, you might find yourself asking: “Should I replace my gutters, too?” It’s a question we hear all the time at Van Martin Roofing. And while the answer depends on a few factors, one thing’s clear: when your roof and gutters work together, your home stays drier, safer, and better protected. Let’s walk through the benefits of coordinating your roof replacement in Columbus, Ohio with a new gutter system—and why doing both at once could save you money and headaches in the long run.

Roof and Gutters: A System Built to Protect

Your roof and gutters aren’t just neighbors—they’re teammates. When functioning correctly, they work together to manage rainwater and protect every part of your home’s exterior and interior.

How Gutters Complement a New Roof

Gutters channel water away from your foundation, basement, and landscaping. If they’re leaking, sagging, or misaligned, they can’t do their job—even if your new roof is flawless.

  • Prevent Water Damage: Properly installed gutters reduce risk of water infiltration into siding, basement, and crawl spaces.

  • Preserve Foundation Integrity: Redirecting runoff keeps water from pooling at your home’s base, preventing cracks and erosion.

  • Protect Your Landscaping: No more mini lakes near your flower beds or eroded mulch after heavy rainstorms.

House with Gutters Holding Water

Why Replace Your Gutters During a Roof Replacement?

When your roof and gutters are installed together, it’s like assembling a team with shared goals. At Van Martin Roofing, we’ve seen how coordinating these systems improves longevity, performance, and aesthetics.

Three Big Reasons to Combine Roof and Gutter Replacement

If you’re already replacing your roof, here’s why upgrading the gutters at the same time makes sense:

  • ✅ Seamless Integration: Our crews ensure your gutters fit the roofline perfectly, minimizing misalignment and potential water intrusion.

  • ✅ Unified Warranty: Both roof and gutter installations are covered by our exclusive VanGuard Lifetime Workmanship Warranty.

  • ✅ Efficient Project Management: One crew, one timeline, one contract—it’s the easiest way to check two critical home upgrades off your list.

Stone-coated-metal-shingle-14.jpg

Are Your Gutters Ready to Go?

Just because you’re getting a new roof doesn’t mean your gutters have to go—yet. At Van Martin Roofing, we educate before we replace. Our no-pressure assessments tell the whole story of your roof and your gutters so you can make an informed decision.

Free Gutter + Roof Evaluation in Columbus

We examine signs of gutter wear that often go unnoticed until it’s too late:

  • Visible sagging or pulling away from the fascia board.

  • Rust, holes, or cracking along gutter seams and troughs.

  • Overflow during rainfall, indicating clogs or improper pitch.

If your gutters still have years left, we’ll tell you. And if not? We’ll show you exactly what needs to change—and why—with complete transparency.

Raindrops on glass, dark green background, moody.

Our Trusted Process for Roofing & Gutter Replacement

As a residential roofing contractor in Columbus, our process is built on clarity, communication, and craftsmanship. Whether it’s a 25-year-old shingle roof or an aging aluminum gutter system, our approach remains the same: do it right the first time.

From Estimate to Install—What You Can Expect

  • Step 1: We assess both roof and gutters during a detailed onsite visit.

  • Step 2: You receive a no-obligation estimate that outlines options, costs, and expected lifespan of each system.

  • Step 3: Upon approval, our certified installers begin work, with daily progress updates from your project manager.

  • Step 4: Once complete, you receive our signature VanGuard Warranty—a true lifetime promise.

With over 900 Google reviews and an A+ BBB rating, our customers trust that we’ll treat their home like it’s our own—because we do.

When Should You NOT Replace Your Gutters?

There are times when keeping your current gutters makes more sense. If they’re less than 10 years old, properly aligned, and free of leaks or rust, you might be in the clear. But even then, our experts will check compatibility with your new roofing system.

Quick Compatibility Checklist

  • Are your gutters properly pitched for drainage?

  • Do they match the new roof color or style?

  • Will existing hangers or downspouts interfere with new materials?

If the answer to any of these is “no,” it may be worth the added efficiency—and peace of mind—to tackle both at once.

The Bonus of a Unified Warranty

Choosing Van Martin means everything we install is protected by our exclusive VanGuard Lifetime Workmanship Warranty. When both roof and gutters are installed together, you’re not only getting efficiency—you’re also getting coverage that simplifies future maintenance or repairs.

Warranty Benefits Homeowners Love

  • One Point of Contact: If an issue arises, we handle both systems—no finger-pointing.

  • Complete Coverage: Workmanship issues are covered for life. Period.

  • Boosted Resale Value: Prospective buyers love transferable warranties—it shows the home’s been well-cared for.

Serving Columbus, One Roof and Gutter at a Time

From Westerville to Hilliard, Upper Arlington to Grove City, Van Martin Roofing is proud to protect homes throughout Central Ohio. We don’t upsell—we educate. We don’t disappear—we partner with you long after the job is done. That’s the Van Martin difference.

So if you’re on the fence about whether to replace your gutters during a roof replacement in Columbus, Ohio, let us guide you. We’ll give you the clear facts, a custom plan, and a result that looks as good as it performs.

Conclusion

Your roof and gutters form the first line of defense for your home. Upgrading them together means fewer headaches, better performance, and long-term savings. Whether you’re dealing with failing gutters or just looking to maximize your investment, our team is ready to help with clarity, care, and craftsmanship.

📅 Book your free roof and gutter evaluation today. Call (937) 222-7855 or visit Van Martin Roofing Columbus to schedule your appointment. Let’s build a roof and gutter system that lasts a lifetime.

Scroll to Top