Asphalt or metal? It’s the question echoing across Ohio forums these past few months. We replace thousands of roofs from Dayton to Columbus, and the answer depends on durability goals, energy savings, and budget comfort. Let’s compare options through the lens of real weather, not marketing fluff.

Durability Face-Off

Traditional shingles last 20–25 years—unless 70-mph winds yank them early. Our impact-rated CertainTeed lines resist hail dents and maintain seal strips in 100°F heat. Metal, however, laughs at uplift pressures up to 120-mph, making it ideal near open fields where gusts roar.

Energy Efficiency

Heat-reflective asphalt and Solaris® cool shingle colors drop attic temps by as much as 30°F. Standing-seam metal goes further, rebounding solar radiation and pairing nicely with radiant barriers.

• Asphalt: Lower upfront cost, wide color palette.

• Metal: 50-year lifespan, recyclable, lighter on rafters.

• Both: Eligible for our VanGuard Lifetime Warranty when installed by SELECT crews.

“Our 120-mph rated metal panels won’t budge—ask your neighbor who slept through last night’s storm.”

Van Martin Roofing Customer, June 2025

Total Cost of Ownership

Metal’s sticker shock fades when you factor zero replacement for half a century. Our financing options let you trade interest on repairs for equity-boosting upgrades now.

Noise & Aesthetics Myths

Modern metal uses plywood decking and underlayment to muffle raindrops. Profiles mimic cedar shakes or sleek lines, so HOA fears melt away.

Decision Time

Still split? We provide a digital measurement report plus side-by-side material ROI so you choose confidently.

Evaluate. Educate. Protect. Book a free inspection today.